Is Frozen Yogurt Healthier Than Ice Cream

Frozen yogurt is one of the most popular frozen desserts in America.  It’s also the latest food trend, with new shops opening all over the country to meet demand from consumers looking for a healthier ice cream alternative. And while it may seem that froyo is as good or better than regular ice cream for your waistline and health, many people are still wary about eating it because they think it’s not as healthy. So let’s take a closer look at what makes up each type of dessert so you can decide which is really more nutritious and less harmful to your body.

A glance at their ingredients list reveals some important differences between frozen yogurt and ice cream: Frozen yogurt contains live active cultures—a probiotic that helps promote healthy digestion and immunity; ice cream typically does not.

The ingredients in frozen yogurt are also simpler to pronounce and understand: milk, sugar, and some type of thickeners like pectin or fruit puree. Ice cream ingredients, on the other hand, include stabilizers like cellulose gum and guar gum to maintain the texture of the dessert.

Sample nutrition facts labels for 16-ounce servings show how similar these two desserts actually are when you look at their basic stats: calories, fat, saturated fat (the types that raise cholesterol levels), sodium, and even protein content. Both boast around 200 calories per serving and contain about four grams of fat—2.5 grams each from saturated fat —and 12-14 grams of sugar.

The nutrition facts label reveals that frozen yogurt and ice cream are pretty much similar in their nutritional value. In fact, the only real differences lie in their serving size—one cup vs. one pint of ice cream—and how many ingredients make up each dessert: about three for fat-free frozen yogurt, and around 15 for ice cream (thanks to all those stabilizers). If benefits like better digestion or fewer additives sound good to you, then grab a froyo on your next hot day out. If the calorie count is more important —or if you’re just really craving the full flavor of ice cream —then your best bet will be sticking with traditional frozen treats. Either way, eating a healthy diet and exercising regularly should be

1. The difference between ice cream and frozen yogurt

The difference between ice cream and frozen yogurt is that frozen yogurt contains live active cultures- a probiotic that helps promote healthy digestion and immunity. Ice cream typically does not.  Frozen yogurt has ingredients- milk, sugar, and some type of thickeners like pectin or fruit puree, whereas ice cream has ingredients like stabilizers- cellulose gum and guar gum to maintain the texture of the dessert.

Sample nutrition facts label for 16 oz serving shows that frozen yogurt and ice cream have similar nutritional values. It also contains about 200 calories per serving and 4 grams fat each, it is 12-14g sugar respectively.

The only real difference lies in their serving size -one cup vs one pint of ice cream-and how many ingredients make up each dessert: about three for fat-free frozen yogurt, and around 15 for ice cream (thanks to all those stabilizers).

2. How to make your own frozen yogurt

Making frozen yogurt at home is easy and fun, even if you haven’t ever tried it before! The first thing you’ll need to do is find a good recipe. You can start with the basic vanilla or old-fashioned flavor recipes that are online, especially ones that have high ratings. One of my favorite recipes is for Chocolate Frozen Yogurt. It’s very easy to make and tastes like chocolate ice cream!

The main ingredients in frozen yogurt are milk, sugar, and some type of thickening agents like pectin or fruit puree. I recommend using a spoonful of your favorite jelly or jam as the sweetener and berry as the fruit puree. You can also add ginger or cinnamon to enhance the flavor of the frozen yogurt.

Make sure to read the recipe completely and then gather your tools. A gallon of milk, a large pot, a candy thermometer for cooking the mixture, tall glasses or mason jars and lids, a wooden spoon for stirring the dessert as it freezes, rubber gloves so that you won’t burn your hands when handling hot glass containers (if using), and an ice cream maker with paddle attachment are all things that you’ll need to help make frozen yogurt at home.

Mix up the thickening agent into about 2 cups of cold water in a medium saucepan. Then add 1 cup of sugar and bring to boil on high heat until mixture reaches 234 degrees Fahrenheit/115 degrees Celsius. Stir more frequently as the temperature rises.

When the mixture reaches the right temperature, turn off the heat and let it stand until it cools down to 110 degrees Fahrenheit- about 30 minutes. Then add 1 gallon of whole milk (the kind you’d drink, not the non-fat/low-fat variety). You can also use low or reduced-fat milk if you prefer. Stir with a whisk or wooden spoon.

Once all ingredients are incorporated together, pour into tall glasses or mason jars for freezing. To keep frozen yogurt from becoming too watery as it freezes, make sure to leave at least 2 inches at the top of each glass for expansion during the freezing process.

Now just place it in an ice cream maker that has a paddle attachment and churn according to the manufacturer’s instructions. You should have homemade frozen yogurt in about 20 to 25 minutes!

3. Benefits of eating frozen yogurt vs. ice cream

Standard benefits:

  • – Frozen yogurt is a healthier option than ice cream.
  • – It contains live active cultures in comparison to the lack of such ice cream.
  • – With frozen yogurt, you’re treating your body right and giving it what it needs to be healthy and happy.

4. What is the nutritional value of both foods (calories, fat content, etc.)

Frozen yogurt is a healthier option than ice cream.

 Nutritional value of ice cream per 1/2 cup serving:

290 calories; 8g fat (5g Saturated 3g Trans); 65mg Cholesterol; 160mg Sodium; 41g Carbohydrates *Sugar: 39g*; 4g Protein

Nutritionals for Frozen Yogurt per 1 cup serving: 

160 calories; 2.5 grams Fat (.8 Saturated.3 g Trans); 5 mg Cholesterol; 50 mg Sodium; 27 g Carbohydrates ; *Sugar: 26g* ; 3 g Protein

Ice cream is high in saturated fat, cholesterol, and sodium. It is also low in calcium and protein. Minimal amounts of vitamins A, D, B-12, thiamin, and riboflavin are found in ice cream. Doctors do not recommend that a person consume more than one serving of ice cream each week due to the lack of nutrients it contains. Some brands even contain trans fats which increase the risk of developing heart disease and stroke among other conditions.

Frozen yogurt on the other hand contains live active cultures; important ingredients needed to boost your immune system. Frozen yogurt is rich in antioxidants due to its content of fruit juice or berries which helps digest food better and boosts your immune system as well as improves eye health. It is also filled with beneficial nutrients such as calcium, vitamin A, E, and B2. Frozen yogurt is low in saturated fat but high in potassium, protein, riboflavin, and magnesium.

Ice cream has more calories than frozen yogurt because it contains higher amounts of sugar due to its ingredients;

ice cream is made from milk which makes it easier for the body to absorb the necessary glucose that your cells need to function properly!  Frozen yogurt is a healthier option because it’s low in calories, therefore, serving as an alternative that can be incorporated into any diet or meal plan without overdoing it on fats, sugars, or carbohydrates. The nutritional value of both foods varies by brand so make sure you read the nutrition label before ingesting them.

Which one should I eat if I want to lose weight/gain muscle mass or otherwise maintain my current weight-loss goals

If you’re trying to lose weight/gain muscle mass, you might have noticed that there are a lot of conflicting reports about which foods are healthy and which are not. Some sources will tell you frozen yogurt is the best option and others will say ice cream is best. Which one should you eat if you’re looking to maintain your current weight-loss goal?

It depends on whether or not you’re trying to lose weight or gain muscle mass. If your goal is to maintain the same body shape, then it doesn’t matter what food you consume as long as it’s low in calories, sugar, fat, etc.

If your goal is to lose weight, then you should eat whatever you enjoy that is low in calories and high in fiber. Low-fat frozen yogurt might be a good option because it contains fewer calories than ice cream. However, if lowering fat intake isn’t completely necessary for your diet, low sugar or all-natural ice cream would be a better choice since both are lower in calories but high in sugar and carbs.

Both frozen yogurt and ice cream can contain healthy or unhealthy ingredients depending on the brand/type.  Most brands nowadays have at least one flavor of low-fat or non-fat frozen yogurt available which makes choosing a healthier option easier as

Other ways you can enjoy healthy desserts without breaking your diet plan

Frozen yogurt has many good alternatives, such as fruit sorbets, sherbet, and ices. These are all lower in calories and sugar but provide similar flavor and texture to ice cream. Frozen yogurt still contains some fat and can be high in sodium, so it should not be eaten every day or as a replacement for breakfast!

Ice cream is also good for other desserts like pies or brownies. The problem with ice cream is that the majority of brands have very high levels of saturated fat. Luckily, there are now low-fat ices that have only 5g of fat per scoop–a much healthier option!

There are also natural frozen yogurts which contain just 10-20% of the sugar content found in regular frozen yogurt. Natural frozen yogurts are usually made with fruit or vegetables such as beets, raspberries, spinach, or carrots which contain good antioxidants to help reduce the risk of cancer and heart disease.

Ice creams can also be used for desserts by mixing in healthy ingredients like low-fat cottage cheese, skim milk, dried fruits, or nuts. These ingredients add a nutritional punch while still maintaining a sweet dessert treat!

EDIT: This was originally done on BuzzFeed (Click Here ) but I did not see this question anywhere else on Quora so I thought it would make an interesting discussion 🙂

Hope you’ll found this useful!! 🙂

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 0 comments

Leave a Reply: